BNP AM

The sustainable investor for a changing world

Search for

Filter by

Asset class

Economics

Geography

Investing

FRONT OF MIND | ARTICLE – 4 Min

Graph of the week – Monetary policy - ECB has further to go than the Federal Reserve

By ANDREW CRAIG 26.01.2023

In this article:

    Our graph of the week shows that financial markets continue to price a much higher ECB policy rate a year from now than they did before the 15 December meeting of the Governing Council. In contrast, faced with disappointing economic data, lower inflation and somewhat dovish policymaker comments, market expectations for US central bank policy have receded. Do not be fooled: the tightening cycle is not over yet, not in the eurozone and not in the US.

    In December, after the ECB’s most recent monetary policy meeting, President Christine Lagarde sent a hawkish message, insisting that compared to the Fed, the ECB had ‘more ground to cover’ and ‘longer to go’. Markets reacted by pricing in a higher level for forward rates (see red circle on the graph highlighting the sharp rise in expectations).

    Speaking at Davos on 19 January, Ms Lagarde dashed hopes that the ECB’s tightening cycle was ending, suggesting investors would be well advised to ‘revise their position’ for a lower peak for ECB rates because the ECB was determined to ‘stay the course’.

    The rationale for this determination became clear later that day with the publication of the minutes of the ECB’s December meeting. They showed that a large number of governing council members would have preferred to raise rates by 75bp, but agreed to a lower 50bp increase under the explicit assumption that rates would continue to rise at that pace.

    The forward guidance by Ms Lagarde of “another 50 basis points rate hike at our next meeting, and possibly at the one after that, and possibly thereafter” reflects the position of the governing council. The bar for a rapid slowdown in the pace of rate rises looks high indeed.

    US core inflation falling; not in the eurozone

    There is a significant difference between core inflation in the US compared to the eurozone. Core inflation, which excludes changes in the cost of energy and food, is falling in the US, whereas in the eurozone it has been rising, to 5.2% in December up from 5% in November.

    Members of the ECB’s governing council have warned of their concern that elevated inflation could become entrenched via second-round effects. Ms Lagarde pointed out this week that the eurozone’s resilient jobs market could lead to higher wages.

    In contrast, Lael Brainard, the Fed’s vice-chair, signalled in a recent speech that US wages “do not appear to be driving inflation in a 1970s-style wage-price spiral.” She also referred to signs of slacker labour demand and a weakening manufacturing sector as evidence that the US economy is cooling and inflation is on a downward trajectory.

    Here’s what we expect

    At the meeting of FOMC policymakers on 31 January and 1 February, we expect them to raise the US federal funds rate range by 25bp from 4.25-4.5% to 4.5-4.75%. 

    • We expect the FOMC to continue to guide toward a 5.25% terminal rate in the first quarter of 2023
    • The Fed’s message is likely to be hawkish, acknowledging a weakening US economy while simultaneously pledging to ‘stay the course’ and maintain a restrictive policy until inflation is convincingly on its way back to target
    • The meeting statement may downgrade the assessment of current economic activity and signal that while further rate rises are in store, the Fed will be relatively more cautious than when it was in catch-up mode last year
    • Key will be, in our view, what Chair Jerome Powell says in the press conference about the US labour market. Will he be more amenable to the idea of a soft landing than in recent meetings? We’d expect he will continue to emphasise that inflation remains the Fed’s top priority. 

    We expect the fed funds rate to peak at 5.00-5.25% in the first quarter of 2023.

    The ECB’s governing council meets on 2 February. We expect it to follow through on its guidance and raise the deposit rate by 50bp from 2.00% currently and again in March.

    With hard economic data for the fourth quarter of 2023 having come in better than expected and with lower energy prices, the council may see a more positive growth outlook over the short term compared with its December projections. In the absence of updated projections, the ECB will likely stick to its December view of a strong rebound in the second half of 2023 and in 2024.

    We expect further increases in the deposit rate by 25bp each in May and June leading to a terminal policy rate of 3.50%. The market is currently pricing a slightly lower terminal rate, at 3.34%.

    Why will the ECB keep hiking despite better data?

    In our view, the ECB is in ‘risk management’ mode: it aims to avoid, at all costs, the worst inflation outcomes. A speech by Isabel Schnabel, member of the ECB’s executive board, at Jackson Hole in August 2022, outlines the approach: 

    There are two broad paths central banks can take to deal with current high inflation: one is a path of caution, in line with the view that monetary policy is the wrong medicine to deal with supply shocks. The other path is one of determination. On this path, monetary policy responds more forcefully to the current bout of inflation, even at the risk of lower growth and higher unemployment. This is the “robust control” approach to monetary policy that minimises the risks of very bad economic outcomes in the future. Three broad observations speak in favour of central banks choosing the latter path: the uncertainty about the persistence of inflation, the threats to central bank credibility and the potential costs of acting too late.” 

    The good news is that the ECB will stand ready to ease monetary policy as soon as there is evidence that the risk of ‘very bad outcomes’ has faded. We do not expect such news in the first half of 2023.

    The ECB expects core inflation to start falling in the third quarter of 2023. Until then, barring major downward surprises to core inflation, the central bank is likely to judge any change in their overall policy stance as premature.

    Disclaimer

    Please note that articles may contain technical language. For this reason, they may not be suitable for readers without professional investment experience. Any views expressed here are those of the author as of the date of publication, are based on available information, and are subject to change without notice. Individual portfolio management teams may hold different views and may take different investment decisions for different clients. This document does not constitute investment advice. The value of investments and the income they generate may go down as well as up and it is possible that investors will not recover their initial outlay. Past performance is no guarantee for future returns. Investing in emerging markets, or specialised or restricted sectors is likely to be subject to a higher-than-average volatility due to a high degree of concentration, greater uncertainty because less information is available, there is less liquidity or due to greater sensitivity to changes in market conditions (social, political and economic conditions). Some emerging markets offer less security than the majority of international developed markets. For this reason, services for portfolio transactions, liquidation and conservation on behalf of funds invested in emerging markets may carry greater risk.

    Related posts

    Weekly Market Update – A very gradual recovery in the eurozone economy
    Front of mind | Article - 3 Min

    Weekly Market Update – A very gradual recovery in the eurozone economy

    Recent data suggests the eurozone is gradually recovering, but underlines a state of economic divergence, with Germany in particular lagging...

    ANDREW CRAIG
    | 29.02.2024
    Graph of the week – Q1 2024, a tipping point for a new computer era?
    Front of mind | Article - 1 Min

    Graph of the week – Q1 2024, a tipping point for a new computer era?

    In February, a sharp rise in quarterly revenues reported by leading US manufacturers of semiconductor chips have further boosted the...

    ANDREW CRAIG
    | 28.02.2024

    Viewpoint highlights

    Subscribe to receive this week’s articles straight to your inbox.

    Please enter a valid email
    Please check the boxes below to subscribe

    FOLLOW VIEWPOINT

    Receive daily updates